For many Palestinians, the Board of Peace – and the international community’s failure to act in the face of overwhelming evidence of Israeli obstructionism – reflect a profound abandonment: While they struggle to survive, political progress is being prevented.
“I just know that this world has let down the Palestinians,” said a senior Palestinian aid worker in Gaza. “I’m just busy surviving and trying to put my life back together, while the political process somehow remains stuck – though I find it very difficult to describe it stuck, because it’s not stuck. There is a deliberate decision not to move things forward.”
With winter beginning, needs in Gaza are nearly identical to those before last winter. Palestinians are facing the same problems – from inadequate shelter and food insecurity to decimated healthcare and education sectors – made worse by a year of stagnation and attrition.
The humanitarian response is hanging on, but it is increasingly ground down by dwindling funding and continued Israeli restrictions on what can enter Gaza and on how NGOs can operate. “Nothing moves, nothing changes, nothing improves,” said one international aid worker, summarising the situation.
The New Humanitarian spoke with more than a dozen Palestinian and international aid workers familiar with the response in Gaza for this article. Most spoke anonymously because of concerns that Israeli authorities would retaliate against their organisations.
Many senior aid workers said the Board of Peace has achieved nothing on the ground. Instead, they argue, it has become a fig leaf for powerful countries looking to deflect public pressure for meaningful action on Gaza. “We all have to kind of pretend that it will work… as if it’s [all that] we have left,” the international aid worker said.
A spokesperson for the Board of Peace did not respond to The New Humanitarian’s request for comment.
Meanwhile, Israeli attacks have killed an average of four people per day in Gaza since the ceasefire agreement came into effect on 10 October 2025. Nearly all of Gaza’s population of 2.1 million people are displaced – living in tents and war-damaged buildings – and Israeli soldiers continue to directly occupy around 65% of the enclave.
None of the aid workers The New Humanitarian spoke to were hopeful recent Israeli elections would bring positive change. Candidates across the spectrum of Israel’s Jewish political parties have promised more of the same – or even more extreme policies – for Palestinians.
The onset of winter weather and storms – already causing deaths, flooding, and displacement – has laid bare the consequences of the Board of Peace’s ineffectiveness, and the paralysis in Gaza.
“Everyone in Gaza was just putting up with all of the struggles in their lives, thinking that, yes, there will be an end to this. It’s ended – but then everything for Palestinians living in Gaza continued. They continued queuing for water, continued worrying about their families because there are still ongoing, random strikes,” said the senior Palestinian aid worker.
“Can Palestinians find work? Can they find education? Can they regain some dignity and control over their lives? No,” the aid worker said. “We’ve been in this cycle where we manage the humanitarian consequences of this war, without addressing the political cause.”
Insufficient workarounds and Israeli restrictions
The Board has so far not convinced Israel to allow representatives of the caretaker authority, the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza, into the Strip to take over governance from Hamas, which dissolved its government in July to make way for the new authority. The armed group maintains security control in parts of Gaza where Israeli troops or their proxy militias are not present on the ground, while day-to-day governance rests on a mix of surviving civil servants backed up by local leadership, including neighbourhood and family groups.
With no progress towards reconstruction and Israeli restrictions ongoing, humanitarian organisations have been left to find seemingly endless workarounds to try to address needs as basic as water.
In April, humanitarian organisations lost access to one of Gaza’s main water sources in the north of the Strip after Israeli forces shot and killed two Palestinian truckers working for UNICEF. The water source, in the Shuja’iyya neighbourhood east of Gaza City, is now on the Israeli-controlled side of the so-called yellow line dividing the territory.
Following negotiations with Israeli authorities, aid workers regained access to the water source. But safety is still a major concern, with Israeli soldiers regularly firing on civilians and aid workers near the yellow line. UNICEF initially sent teams to accompany the water trucks after access was restored – in effect human shields for civilian drivers, as one aid worker with an international NGO put it.
Israeli forces have continued to attack water infrastructure throughout the ceasefire, including strikes on water collection points in Gaza City on 20 April and 5 July, desalination plants in southern Gaza on 25 March and on 24 August, and in Gaza City on the same day. Troops fired on municipal water employees in Beit Lahia in September. The following month, the Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group, reported two incidents of Israeli fire near its aid workers distributing water.
Meanwhile, repairs to larger water infrastructure, which is mostly on the Israeli-controlled side of the yellow line, remain held up by Israel’s refusal to allow in needed materials or to coordinate with aid workers to allow them to access areas under its control.
With larger projects mostly blocked, humanitarians have recently focused on smaller neighbourhood water sources – from new groundwater wells to small-scale desalination projects – with UNICEF rehabilitating at least 32 this year that now serve about a quarter of a million people.
The idea is to reduce time travelling to and queuing at water points, where people are exposed to Israeli military fire. There is another purpose as well, a second international aid worker said: Spreading out the system makes it somewhat less vulnerable to Israel’s frequent strikes on water infrastructure, essentially providing many small targets instead of a few big ones.
When Israel has approved water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) equipment for import recently, this has been largely contingent on its use in places approved by Israel in southern and western Gaza, where Israeli authorities have tried to push people since the beginning of their military campaign, the senior Palestinian aid worker said.
A Board of Peace working group set up in August to prioritise WASH fixes – after untreated sewage from Gaza created algae blooms that disrupted Israel’s water supply – has failed to make progress, aid workers added.
Trucking – an expensive emergency solution – remains the main source of water for about three quarters of Gaza households, according to UNICEF. But Israeli restrictions on fuel and engine oil have made trucking so costly that some international NGOs said they will likely need to reduce or stop it next year.
A spokesperson for COGAT, the Israeli military unit responsible for coordinating with humanitarians, responded to The New Humanitarian’s questions about Israel’s well-documented restrictions by saying: “The claim is biased and disregards the fact that Hamas exploits humanitarian aid and the civilian environment for its military buildup.”
“No equipment intended for the reconstruction of the Gaza Strip will be permitted to enter until Hamas has been fully and verifiably disarmed,” the spokesperson said in a written statement.
COGAT said the military provides “international organisations and local merchants alternative solutions that address humanitarian needs” and claimed to have facilitated the entry of medical equipment, engine oil, and generator spare parts. All of these items are in critically short supply as a result of Israeli restrictions, according to aid workers.
Humanitarians have documented a longstanding pattern of denials. Data shared with The New Humanitarian showing Israeli decisions in the first week of November on UN and NGO requests to bring items into Gaza provides a snapshot: COGAT rejected just over a third of all requests, including three-quarters made by NGOs. Refused items included diapers, drinking water, and about 5,200 blankets. Tarpaulins, mattresses, and nails and hardware to weather-proof shelters were also turned back: as the weather worsens, Israeli authorities rejected about as much shelter cargo as they approved.
Overall, the most common reason for denial, at 44%, was “non-compliance” with Israeli policy. That policy has never been articulated to humanitarians, a senior aid worker explained – but this week in November it apparently forbade items including engine oil, tires, hygiene supplies, firefighting gear, and flashlights.
Another 19% of requests were denied for what Israeli authorities said were security reasons – including solar panels, a dough mixer, and IV fluids – and 14% because the item requested didn’t fit requirements. An autoclave for sterilisation, for example, was too big; a desalination unit’s membrane was off by millimetres. About 700 wool blankets were rejected for no stated reason.
Fuel and oil shortages
The shortage of fuel and engine oil resulting from Israeli restrictions – supposed to be lifted after the ceasefire – has been disastrous across the humanitarian response, affecting everything from ambulances to water treatment facilities and hospitals still running on generators worn down by constant use.
Israel limits UN imports and blocks most aid organisations from directly importing their own supplies under restrictive NGO registration rules, leaving most to find oil on the private market, where supplies are limited and prices extortionate.
In October, the Danish Refugee Council (DRC) had eight vehicles needing oil changes, but at just over $900 per litre in Gaza, an oil change for all eight would cost about $30,000. “Multiply this across all of the vehicles that are needed to deliver aid, and think about all of the actual assistance that could be purchased with that money that we’re having to spend just to change the oil,” said Alan Moseley, the DRC country director.
Gaza also still has no electricity supply, which Israeli authorities cut in October 2023. At night, the brightest and often only lights come from flood lights illuminating the rubble-strewn perimeters of the more than 50 Israeli military outposts, many of which have been built or expanded since the ceasefire agreement.
Gaza’s critical infrastructure runs on generators, most operating 24/7. Solar panels supplement some of this, but what is available can’t provide enough power to run large machinery – and aid groups say this will only worsen with darker winter days.
“I don’t want us to normalise the obstacles, as if we’re talking about trying to reach people on a distant mountain where the conditions are just inherently difficult,” Moseley said.
“IHL (international humanitarian law) is quite clear and is specific and unambiguous about the obligations of parties to a conflict, the obligations of an occupying power. Those obligations are to facilitate and enable the provision of humanitarian assistance. All of the challenges that we talk about… these are things that are not only manufactured through policy choices, but they also… cumulatively demonstrate violation of IHL,” he said.
Random gunfire and forced displacement
Apparently indiscriminate Israeli gunfire and attacks are a recurring threat to Palestinian civilians across Gaza. Palestinians have been killed and wounded in their tents, classrooms, schools-turned-shelters, and medical clinics.
Last year, Medical Aid for Palestinians (MAP) was able to find space at the crowded Nasser Hospital to restart a chemotherapy clinic, which had served nearly 3,000 patients at the European Hospital before repeated Israeli attacks forced the hospital to close in May 2025. But Nasser is now also being routinely hit.
Already a frequent Israeli military target over the past three years, the hospital has been hit increasingly since September by bullets apparently fired from the direction of the yellow line, MAP reported.
“Even those who are living in the areas considered out of Israeli control are under fire from the Israelis on a daily basis. There is no safe place in Gaza, and people have to struggle for their lives.”
On 18 October, a hospital security guard and four other civilians were shot in or just outside the hospital, and a bullet – likely from an Israeli quadcopter – went through the window of the neonatal intensive care unit, MAP reported. On 12 November, an Israeli airstrike killed six people in the hospital, including a surgeon and a 13-year-old boy.
“Even those who are living in the areas considered out of Israeli control are under fire from the Israelis on a daily basis. There is no safe place in Gaza, and people have to struggle for their lives,” said Fikr Shalltoot, MAP’s Gaza director.
Nasser is about two kilometres directly west of the only remaining gap in a sand berm built by Israeli forces along the yellow line in the southern half of Gaza. Satellite images show Israeli forces closing the gap and demolishing homes – as they have done in other parts of Gaza under their direct control – in the area since September. An aid worker familiar with the situation said the gunfire hitting Nasser appears to be coming from troops shooting to clear the area for bulldozers.
Closer to the yellow line, there are no medical services. Accessing care in northern Gaza requires going to Gaza City – a now arduous journey. For many families, particularly those with elderly, children, or pregnant women and others needing regular care, this can push them to flee to other parts of Gaza, explained Shalltoot. “Some of these people feel they have no choice,” she said.
In recent conversations, aid organisations described difficult calculations about where to try to restore services, knowing Israeli attacks may happen at any moment in the about 35% of the Strip nominally under Palestinian control.
But at the same time, aid workers have said they worry pulling back will create dead zones without services, unintentionally making it easier for Israel to push Palestinians out of more territory.
“There’s this tension where we are trying to expand the areas where people have access to essentials and can live, while Israel shrinks the space and moves the boundaries, making it harder for us to reach those spaces – making it more likely that people will be displaced,” said the second international aid worker.
“Then there’s the question: Are we investing our limited resources in areas where we might not have access and people may no longer be living within a few weeks or months?” they added.
Winter supply shortages and donor politics
Around half of Gaza’s population is living in areas at risk of flooding. Rainstorms in early November flooded around 70,000 tents, affecting some 350,000 people. Almost the entire population is in need of shelter assistance. What is currently available in the pipeline is nowhere close to enough, and the UN’s winterisation appeal is still only about 30% funded.
In a recent DRC survey, people living in displacement camps reported an overwhelming list of concerns – from frequent Israeli gunfire and open cesspools to rat infestations and stray dogs, which have become so bad that neighbourhoods are organising night watches to patrol for animals.
As disastrous as the situation was ahead of last winter, humanitarians were in a better position to respond, several aid workers said. Some international NGOs with long-running programmes in Gaza – now subject to Israeli ban – could still bring in supplies. There was also more aid pre-positioned outside the enclave.
“We’re anticipating a winter that’s much worse, because there’s such little supply getting in and a huge funding gap,” said Shaina Low, with the Norwegian Refugee Council.
The tents and tarpaulins housing most Palestinians in Gaza were not meant to be permanent. Just over half of households will be on their second winter in the same tent this year, and 16% on their third, according to the Palestine shelter cluster, a consortium of aid agencies coordinating winterisation efforts.
More durable shelter materials are still held up by Israel’s restriction on items it considers to have dual civilian and military uses. This includes a recent shipment by a shelter cluster NGO of kitchen utensils, turned back because it contained butter knives, which Israeli authorities said could have a military use.
Multiple aid workers described exasperating conversations with European and North American diplomats about the now well-worn subject of Israeli obstruction, and a similarly well-worn pattern from those states: private expressions of understanding and solidarity, public statements of concern, little or no meaningful political or economic pressure on Israeli authorities to stop. “The capitals know what’s going on, and yet for political reasons they choose not to act,” the second international aid worker said.
Conversations with donor countries are spent describing the situation on the ground, in the hopes that somehow more evidence will help. “I do it for my work, but as a Palestinian, I feel they know… There has been enough evidence,” the first Palestinian aid worker said.
The Board of Peace’s role
At the centre of the paralysis is the Board of Peace: The ceasefire it is tasked with overseeing is violated at will and without consequence by Israel, which also obstructs the humanitarian aid the board was supposed to help enter into Gaza, and the redevelopment it was supposed to manage.
Multiple aid workers reported from recent conversations with diplomats that the consensus among European states is that the Trump-led peace project is going nowhere – “a complete failure”, a third international aid worker said, summarising opinions heard in those conversations.
This candid assessment is at odds with public statements from most of these governments, who have largely sat on the fence, at once not fully endorsing the Board, while supporting the peace plan it is mandated to implement as the only path forward.
“The time we all waste – and the whole international community is wasting – investing people, resources, money on mechanisms that are set for failure,” said the first international aid worker. European governments in particular have publicly locked onto the idea that the Board of Peace is the only alternative, they said.
The apparent strategy is to avoid upsetting Trump. “It’s like, ‘Don’t wake the baby,’” the third international aid worker.
Rather than a reconstruction effort grounded in the needs, rights, and aspirations of the people that live in Gaza, it has left Palestinians in the Strip and aid organisations to try to weather an untenable status quo.
“Why are laboratories not available? Why are medications for cancer patients not allowed?… Drugs, still 47% at zero stock. Medical disposables, 54% at zero stock. Laboratory agents, 80% at zero stock. I just don’t understand. What risk? What justification could be used?” asked Shalltoot, MAP’s Gaza director.
“Why does all the population in Gaza have to live in darkness? Why? If what’s been happening is not ethnic cleansing or a genocidal act, why is all this happening for civilian people in Gaza?” Shalltoot said.
Her own sister, Muyaser, died in Gaza last year, and her brother Mohammed, the year prior, both from medical conditions aggravated by the dire conditions and a lack of access to healthcare. In her sister’s case, it was a chronic kidney condition that became fatal because she couldn’t get transportation to a doctor. “When they got her to the hospital, it was too late,” Shalltoot said.
Her siblings are not counted among the nearly 75,000 killed in Gaza since October 2023 – but such cases have become a daily reality, Shalltoot said: “It becomes something that we live with.”
This article is republished from thenewhumanitarian under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Canadian journalist covering Gaza, migration, and human rights
